Should I use Genki or Minna no Nihongo?
Quick Answer
Choose Genki for self-study with English support. Choose Minna no Nihongo for classroom learning or immersive Japanese-only approach.
Genki and Minna no Nihongo are the two most popular Japanese beginner textbooks. Here's a detailed comparison:
Genki
- Language: English explanations - Best for: Self-study learners - Approach: Integrated skills with cultural notes - Style: Modern, conversational dialogues - Workbook: Sold separately - Online resources: Extensive community support - Levels covered: N5-N4 (Genki I & II)
Minna no Nihongo
- Language: Japanese only (separate translation book needed) - Best for: Classroom with teacher guidance - Approach: Grammar-focused with extensive drills - Style: More formal, traditional - Workbook: Included exercises + separate books available - Online resources: Official materials - Levels covered: N5-N4 (Minna I & II)
Choose Genki if you
- Are self-studying without a teacher - Prefer English explanations for grammar - Want modern, casual Japanese - Value cultural context and notes - Learn better with integrated approach
Choose Minna no Nihongo if you
- Have a teacher or are in a class - Want immersive Japanese-only learning - Prefer intensive grammar drilling - Plan to study in Japan - Want more formal Japanese foundation
**Can't go wrong with either!** Both successfully teach N5-N4 content. Your learning style and study environment matter more than which book is "better."
Key Takeaways
- 1Genki: English explanations, self-study friendly
- 2Minna: Japanese-only, classroom oriented
- 3Both cover N5-N4 level content equally well
- 4Learning style and environment matter most
- 5Complete one series fully before switching
Have More Questions?
Browse our complete FAQ library or find the perfect study materials for your JLPT journey.